Organic Wine, Oh My!

Sorting Out Organic Grapes vs. Organic Wine!

From the Drinking with the Juiceman Newsletter…Subscribe Here

Suflites in Organic Wines

Suflites in Organic Wines

What is Organic Wine?

I am frequently asked what it means when a wine is “organic.” Here’s a fundamental way to understand what it means. There is a difference between “organically grown” grapes and wines that are “organically made.” This is a huge distinction!

Organically Made

If you label a wine organic, it means the wine cannot have sulfites added to prolong its shelf life; they must be certified to contain no more than ten parts per million of naturally occurring sulfites. 

Made from Organic Grapes

If a wine comes from organic grapes, it must say, “made from organic grapes.” Wines made with organically grown grapes come from vineyards that follow the guidelines set by Organic Certifications, which can vary by country. They have no non-organic crop protection materials in them. 

They can only contain organically approved materials for pesticides, insecticides, herbicides, and bactericides (some synthetic materials are allowed). This is good, in theory, because you are not affecting the grapes. It can be troublesome, though, because you are not protecting the grapes; you are letting whatever happens to the grapes naturally happen, good or bad. Grape juice has sugar. Sugar attracts bugs, disease, and all kinds of other things that can destroy the grape juice on it’s way to becoming wine. Adding sulfites provides the grape with a protective blanket of sorts that can keep those unwarranted influences away from the grapes.

So What Should I Drink?

In theory, wines made with organic grapes should be better wines because they are made with a higher quality of fruit. But it depends on who’s making the wine. In the right hands, it’s terrific. In a lesser winemaker’s hands, the word “organic” won’t save the wine. I learned this from my good friend, Robert Sinskey. He’s been making wine from organic grapes since the 1980s. When Sinskey looked first around at his soil in Napa Valley, it was dead. There were no birds, no worms; there was no ecosystem. Nothing was living in this soil, so how can the grapes live? Sinskey made the conversion to organic grapes and never looked back, but it’s his skilled winemaking that brings the quality of those grapes to fruition in the bottle. 

Organic winemaking may sound sexy, but it requires stringent measures that may require the wine not to be made organically or labeled organic. Doing the minimal amount necessary to protect the grapes will still not meet the standards of being labeled “organic.” So though a wine like Sinskey’s is made from organic grapes and not labeled organic, you will be getting a high-quality wine that has taken great care to grow the grapes organically and protect them with as minimal treatment as possible to preserve their value and quality all the way to your glass.

Below are a few of the standard Organic icons you can look for on a bottle of wine in your journey to find Organically Farmed wines. 

Organic Certifications

Organic Certifications

2 Comments on “Organic Wine, Oh My!

  1. I think 100ppm SO2 is way to high for a typical organic wine. Most artisan producers are in the 30-40ppm. We typically bottle our reds in the 20-25pmm range.

    Paul Gordon
    Halcon Vineyards

    • Hey Paul – Thanks for the comment! I knew there would be a few comments here as this info is choppy waters, and there are many opinions, especially from winemakers. It’s interesting to write about this because my audience has somms, wine pros, winemakers, and consumers, so I have to toggle between serious and surface.

      I agree 100ppm is high, but I pulled this from the USDA website site -> with this quote – “Finally, sulfites may be added to wines that carry the “made with organic grapes” label—up to 100 parts per million.” I figure this is as solid a source as I can get.

      On another note, I’ve never tasted Halcon wines! I see you are getting some good write-ups from Dunnick and Vinous… I used to work with a winery, Phillips Hill, years ago that had Oppenlander fruit. Good stuff!

      Thanks again for the note, and please feel free to correct or challenge anything you see from my end!

      On another, another, note, I also do a newsletter where this story was pulled from. It’s a work in progress, but my writing partner and I get together once a week and drink a bottle we write up. He’s a HUGE Rhône lover. We crushed a bottle of Tensley Tensley this week!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *